Bug in Money 2004 thru 2007

If you buy 2 lots of a mutual fund and then sell or transfer some of the
shares (quantity greater than the original number of shares purchased in the
first lot), the cost basis is incorrect.

I demonstrated this to Microsoft and they agreed the results are wrong but
they say "that is the way the program is designed", it is not a bug.

To prove the bug for yourself, perform the following transactions.

In investment account #1
6/1/2004 buy 422.9 shares of mutual fund FMIMX at a price of 19.00 and no 
commissions
2/1/2005 buy 795 shares of mutual fund FMIMX at a price of 22.00 and no 
commissions
10/26/2006 transfer 500 shares of mutual fund FMIMX from this account to 
investment account #2

In the above example the 2 purchases of FMIMX cost a total of $25,525.10. 
Now go to the Portfolio view and look at the "cost basis" column grand total 
and it shows $24,777.26 thereby increasing your capital gains reported to 
the IRS.

If enough people call Microsoft about it maybe they will fix it.  Right now 
you may be reporting incorrect capital gains to the IRS (my examples lowers 
the cost basis and would raise your capital gains amount).



-- 

Neil



0
10/27/2006 12:31:09 AM
money 28651 articles. 7 followers. Follow

4 Replies
1095 Views

Similar Articles

[PageSpeed] 35

Some comments inline. I haven't checked your case and am not commenting on 
that.

"Remove ABCD from Email address to reply" <neil154ABCD@earthlink.net> wrote 
in message news:eqE%23z8V%23GHA.4708@TK2MSFTNGP05.phx.gbl...
> I demonstrated this to Microsoft and they agreed the results are wrong but
> they say "that is the way the program is designed", it is not a bug.

Most support organizations will say this even if the app adds 2+2 and says 
the answer is 3. By most accounts, the Money group isn't much worse than 
that.

> ... thereby increasing your capital gains reported to the IRS.
>
> Right now you may be reporting incorrect capital gains to the IRS (my 
> examples lowers the cost basis and would raise your capital gains amount).

Money doesn't report squat to the IRS. You do. If you take Money's word for 
anything you report without trying to validate what it's telling you, then 
you get what you asked for. Money sells for less than $20. It should get all 
this stuff right. It doesn't. Even if it was perfect for nominal scenarios, 
there are always going to be cases too complicated or confused for most any 
pre-canned tool like Money (or SAP, for that matter) to handle. 


0
10/27/2006 1:00:03 AM
I don't disagree with your comments, but if people are aware of the bug then 
they will pay more attention.

-- 

Neil


"Dick Watson" <littlegreengecko@mind-enufalready-spring.com> wrote in 
message news:u76YkWW%23GHA.1224@TK2MSFTNGP05.phx.gbl...
> Some comments inline. I haven't checked your case and am not commenting on 
> that.
>
> "Remove ABCD from Email address to reply" <neil154ABCD@earthlink.net> 
> wrote in message news:eqE%23z8V%23GHA.4708@TK2MSFTNGP05.phx.gbl...
>> I demonstrated this to Microsoft and they agreed the results are wrong 
>> but
>> they say "that is the way the program is designed", it is not a bug.
>
> Most support organizations will say this even if the app adds 2+2 and says 
> the answer is 3. By most accounts, the Money group isn't much worse than 
> that.
>
>> ... thereby increasing your capital gains reported to the IRS.
>>
>> Right now you may be reporting incorrect capital gains to the IRS (my 
>> examples lowers the cost basis and would raise your capital gains 
>> amount).
>
> Money doesn't report squat to the IRS. You do. If you take Money's word 
> for anything you report without trying to validate what it's telling you, 
> then you get what you asked for. Money sells for less than $20. It should 
> get all this stuff right. It doesn't. Even if it was perfect for nominal 
> scenarios, there are always going to be cases too complicated or confused 
> for most any pre-canned tool like Money (or SAP, for that matter) to 
> handle.
> 


0
10/27/2006 2:35:43 AM
This is a rather Microsoft/Dell - type of attitude, Dick.

"Dick Watson" wrote:

> Some comments inline. I haven't checked your case and am not commenting on 
> that.
> 
> "Remove ABCD from Email address to reply" <neil154ABCD@earthlink.net> wrote 
> in message news:eqE%23z8V%23GHA.4708@TK2MSFTNGP05.phx.gbl...
> > I demonstrated this to Microsoft and they agreed the results are wrong but
> > they say "that is the way the program is designed", it is not a bug.
> 
> Most support organizations will say this even if the app adds 2+2 and says 
> the answer is 3. By most accounts, the Money group isn't much worse than 
> that.
> 
> > ... thereby increasing your capital gains reported to the IRS.
> >
> > Right now you may be reporting incorrect capital gains to the IRS (my 
> > examples lowers the cost basis and would raise your capital gains amount).
> 
> Money doesn't report squat to the IRS. You do. If you take Money's word for 
> anything you report without trying to validate what it's telling you, then 
> you get what you asked for. Money sells for less than $20. It should get all 
> this stuff right. It doesn't. Even if it was perfect for nominal scenarios, 
> there are always going to be cases too complicated or confused for most any 
> pre-canned tool like Money (or SAP, for that matter) to handle. 
> 
> 
> 
0
W (121)
11/7/2006 5:48:02 PM
And your better answer is what?

"W'" <W@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message 
news:9A13C9C2-3935-42F3-97A7-3A40217970A6@microsoft.com...
> This is a rather Microsoft/Dell - type of attitude, Dick.
>
> "Dick Watson" wrote:
>
>> Some comments inline. I haven't checked your case and am not commenting 
>> on
>> that.
>>
>> "Remove ABCD from Email address to reply" <neil154ABCD@earthlink.net> 
>> wrote
>> in message news:eqE%23z8V%23GHA.4708@TK2MSFTNGP05.phx.gbl...
>> > I demonstrated this to Microsoft and they agreed the results are wrong 
>> > but
>> > they say "that is the way the program is designed", it is not a bug.
>>
>> Most support organizations will say this even if the app adds 2+2 and 
>> says
>> the answer is 3. By most accounts, the Money group isn't much worse than
>> that.
>>
>> > ... thereby increasing your capital gains reported to the IRS.
>> >
>> > Right now you may be reporting incorrect capital gains to the IRS (my
>> > examples lowers the cost basis and would raise your capital gains 
>> > amount).
>>
>> Money doesn't report squat to the IRS. You do. If you take Money's word 
>> for
>> anything you report without trying to validate what it's telling you, 
>> then
>> you get what you asked for. Money sells for less than $20. It should get 
>> all
>> this stuff right. It doesn't. Even if it was perfect for nominal 
>> scenarios,
>> there are always going to be cases too complicated or confused for most 
>> any
>> pre-canned tool like Money (or SAP, for that matter) to handle.
>>
>>
>> 


0
11/7/2006 7:28:23 PM
Reply:

Similar Artilces:

Somebody sell Office 2007 on web bid
I have found someone are selling Office 2007 on Yahoo, who just sell the key number and say will give the buyer a link on Microsoft to download the whole software. Is it true or false? Is it a legal software? false, if its to good to be true it aint true "hi" <hi@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message news:CD7B3A46-A46E-4A7A-A6B4-39C6610EF1A7@microsoft.com... >I have found someone are selling Office 2007 on Yahoo, who just sell the >key > number and say will give the buyer a link on Microsoft to download the > whole > software. Is it true o...

Can Publisher 2007 be set to save in 2000 format by default
I need to save all files created in Publisher 2007 to save inPublisher 2000 formt. Is there any way of doing this other than using "Save As" Word, Excel and Powerpoint 2007 has the feature. Does it exist in Publisher 2000. I need it to continue having documents compatible with other network users who are using Publisher 2000, XP and 2003. Probably not. The 2000 format tends to make a large file because of the way graphics used to be handled. -- JoAnn Paules MVP Microsoft [Publisher] Tech Editor for "Microsoft Publisher 2007 For Dummies" "RogerL" <R...

Microsoft CRM Report Viewer Bug ? 04-15-07
When viewing report in Microsoft CRM Report Viewer, it extracts the filter info from the RDL file. When user saves the default filter it's also stored in the RDL. The filter info is actually the Fetch XML which is build dynamically by the viewer control. I've created a report and in the RDL file specified the Fetch XML with linked entities and attributes for each linked entity. This way when report is executed, the Fetch XML is converted to the SQL statement which is used as report data (when executed). Report viewer displayes the filter correctly BUT when it builds the Fetch ...

Money Plus Primium in Retail Stores
When Will Microsoft release its new MS Money Plus Premium product in the retail stores? ...

Printing Labels using Access 2007
I am trying to print address labels on an Avery sheet (3 columns by 7 rows), but all I can get is 1 label per A4 page. Can anyone suggest a solution please? Robert Have you tried the Label Wizard in the Reports? Reports | New | Label Wizard It lets you select from among the various Avery label types and automatically configures your columns correctly. Once the wizard has done its thing, you can go in and tweak the format of the labels. HTH Dale "Robert" <nauntons@dial.pipex.com> wrote in message news:AOCdnRnRyf4nEmvbnZ2dneKdnZylnZ2d@pipex.net... >I am trying to...

Importing a CSV file into Money 2003
Help! I'm trying to import all of my brokerage account activity either as a Microsoft native format CSV file or Quicken .QIF file into my Brokerage Account setup in Money 2003 under "Investment Accounts." When I try to import the CSV file into Money, it doesn't recognize my Brokerage Account. What's the deal? Furthermore, at the present time my brokerage company doesn't have the electronically downloadable "direct statement" option. Therefore, the only way to update my brokerage account under Money 2003's Investment Accounts is either by imp...

Lost Cash Flow Function in Money 2002
Not sure what the catalyst was but I have recently lost the ability to view my cash flow forecast. Clicking the toolbar icon does nothing excpet refresh the screen I'm in and the cash flow forecast component of the home page seems stuck on an obscure account. I have tried the Quick Repair, downloaded the Salvage tool & run a Level 2 (Standard) Repair with no effect. However, whilst following the instructions to perform a deep repair, Salv.exe does not allow me to perform the level 3 repair - it does not give that option in the drop-down box. 2 questions... has anyone experien...

Outlook 2007 PST Problem
I am having a problem with my PST folder. Everytime I open up Outlook, it says that need to run SCANPST.exe, to which I have done numerous times, with no luck. I am trying to save as much of my emails as I can. Can anyone help out? Chuck Do you mean that the pst is inaccessible, even after running scanpst? "Chuck" <chuck73@cox.net> wrote in message news:4FAC537D-BDB7-41AB-A406-897DD2C609AA@microsoft.com... > I am having a problem with my PST folder. Everytime I open up Outlook, it > says that need to run SCANPST.exe, to which I have done numerous times, with > ...

Installing Exchange 2007 on Windows 2000 server
We have Windows 2000 SBS, we are thinking of upgrading to SBS 2003. We would also like to upgrade exchange to 2007. Will exchange 2007 install on Win 2000 SBS? Will it install on Win SBS 2003? Can you run exchange 2007 on a member server in SBS 2000 along side Exchange 2000? If so can you configure it to be the gateway and there for use its anti spam features? Exchange 2007 *REQUIRES* a 64 bit OS and must run on 64 bit hardware. There is no upgrade path from any version of Exchange to Exchange 2007. Regards, Hank Arnold Alan M wrote: > We have Windows 2000 SBS, we are thinking of...

Imbedded OLE or Imbedded (Excel) Chart in 2007 Report?
I have previous 2003 OLE MS Graph objects on a report. Can I optimize my report by imbedding the 07 Chart Object instead of the OLE Chart Objects? Is it faster to Load an OLE Chart Object, or run a dynamic 07 Chart Object? Does any of this make sense at all? Thanks. Kou ...

Microsoft Money 2006 Database SDK
Does anyone know of a MS Money DB SDK? I would like to export my Money information to a SQL database so I can create my charts and stuff from it. The SDK would just have to allow read-only access (provided with password) to the Money information. Thanks for any help! See http://umpmfaq.info/faqdb.php?q=10. With MoneyLink you can get some stuff out, but it leaves great holes. (Classification for one has no place in MoneyLink. The memo in a root transaction, for another, is not visible in MoneyLink.) With careful report creation/export and a lot of work importing the reported (and seri...

Does Money Support INternet update from TD Bank ?
I just installed Money 2004. I want to setup direct Internet update from TD Bank, I don't see it under customize updates. Does TD Bank support direct Internet downloads ? If so, how can I find out? If not, which banks in Canada support direct Internet Download ? Thanks There are no banks in Canada which support it right now as far as I know. They are all web-connect... it had something to do with some earlier banking law I think. I know that Quicken XG (CDN) boasted that is supported direct download (with the caveat that the bank had to support it). When I called the rep he said t...

2004 trial file won't open
I tried the trial 2004 version of Money and didn't bite. It saved my file but now won't recognize my password from 2002. Is MS trying to force those who use the free trial to buy 2004 by saving to an unknown password? Please help me recover my file! When the trial upgraded your data file it warned you that Money files, once upgraded, were not backward compatible. See http://umpmfaq.info/faqdb.php?q=84 for the recovery paths. "jmkosloski" <jmkosloski@peopelpc.com> wrote in message news:71ba01c42fe4$3bdd14d0$a101280a@phx.gbl... > I tried the trial 2004 vers...

Powerpoint 2007 03-12-10
I have tried to change the theme or template to an existing presentation but Powerpoint will not apply the change? Suggestions? How are you going about changing the theme/template? What is happening -- or not happening, as the case may be? Which version of PPT? Assuming PPT 2007, you might try hitting the Reset button on Home tab | Slides group (next to the New Slide button). Sometimes if there are a lot of customizations to the slide in question, you have to reset its layout. -- Echo [MS PPT MVP] http://www.echosvoice.com What's new in PPT 2010? http://www.echosvoic...

How to report outlookg bug
I want to report a bug in outlook. How should I do this. Thanks Minhaj ...

Help! Can MONEY Import a MSN online Deluxe Portfolio Backup?
Is there a MONEY version that could import a web based Deluxe MSN Portfolio Backup file? Microsoft is going to Kill thir great portfoloio manager, and many of us have tax lot data stored there, and so far this data is lost in the nep beta programs. I have Money 2002 and I just loaded a moneycentral .mny and a moneycentral ..mbf backup into it with no problem. I have seen that message also and they are crazy. I have been using moneycentral for too many years to remember how far back I started with it. At least early 1990s. During the years I have compared it to many other stock portf...

Testking.co.uk study guides now available with 100% money back guarantee
Testking.co.uk study guides now available with 100% money back guarantee ...

Registry change after upgrade to 2007?
I had changed my Publsiher registry to allow printing of the entire mail merge file when I had Publisher 2003. We have upgraded to 2007. Must the registry be changed again? If so, does the same fix apply? Thank you! ...

Transfers between accounts for Esentials Budget in MM 2007 Deluxe
How can I add a Txfr between accounts into my Essentials Budget in MM 2007 Deluxe? I only have my Checking account in my Budget Accounts list. The only Txfr option on the Pic List I have is "Txfr to to Deleted Acct." Thanks, Van Baird ...

Office 2004 won't reinstall
As soon as I installed Leopard, my Office 2004 apps stopped working. I had never uninstalled Office X and I found that I could still use those apps, although I could *not* double-click on a doc and open it directly. I had to open the app, then choose "open" to get to docs. This was inconvenient, but I dealt with it whilst I looked online and tried to figure out what was going on with 2004. I found a lot of info about how installing Leopard messes up permissions, so I used disk utility to repair permissions. I checked that I had read & write privileges for Office 2004, and I check...

Troubleshoot Outlook calendar update/deletion running Exchange 2007 SP1
Our clients are Office 2003 Pro SP3, server is Exchange 2007 SP1. From time to time, we have complains that deleted meetings don't get to the invitee's calendar, or it's showing updated instead of removing from the calendar. How can I investigate this? I'd assume this has to do with Outlook more than on the Exchange server? Some users have Blackberries and we have BES running, much appreciate your help. ...

Importing a .CSV file into Money 2003
Hello, I am trying to import a .csv file into Money 2003 but using the import option it does not work, does not ask for the target account and this kind of extension is not listed in the import option. I need to import a fidelity investment account activity download and the fidelity site does not offers OFX or QIF extensions. How can I import it? Thanks Not as a .CSV. See http://www.bollar.org/msmoney/#Q8. "Nestor J Portillo" <nportillo@online.hotmail.com> wrote in message news:259c01c3e15c$dceac4c0$a101280a@phx.gbl... > Hello, I am trying to import a .csv file int...

Access 2007 Error message printer information
I have Access 2007 running on Vista. Recently, I am receiving this error message when I try to open a report: "There has been a problem retreiving printer information for this object. The object may have been sent to a printer that is unavailable." There is a default printer which is working for other programs. I cannot print the report from Access. When I try to export the report, I get the error message and nothing exports. Thanks for your assistance. -- John ...

outlook 2007 images
I have 1 person that is using outlook 2007 on a dell laptop. They are unable to view images in their emails. They can see where the images are and if they right click on it, they can copy and paste it into word or mspaint and see them just fine. If they forward teh email to somebody else, they can see the images. I set outlook to automaticly download images. their email format is set to HTML. any ideas? On Feb 7, 10:33=A0am, "Johnfli" <j...@ivhs.us> wrote: > I have 1 person that is using outlook 2007 on a dell laptop. > They are unable to view images in their ema...

Recording myself talk and have background music playing PPT 2007
Hello all, I need to record myself over a PPT but would like background music playing at a lower volume than me speaking. How can I do this with PPT 2007? Sincerely, Geo Record the narration using Slide Show | Record Narration. (I wouldn't use Rehearse Timings in conjunction with Record Narration.) Then add the music background to the presentation separately using Insert | Sound | Sound from File. I believe it will need to be an MP3, not a WAV, because your narrations will be WAVs. On the Sound Tools Options tab that appears when you select the sound icon on the sl...